Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jonah Larsen's avatar

I appreciate the article. It is nice to see our housing crisis improving. But I do have a nagging worry.

How much of this reduction in price is due to fixing supply constraints and how much is due to less immigration? Immigration is generally good for the economy. On average more immigration makes us all wealthier.

Now surely there is some optimal amount of immigration based on balancing different economic factors and I won't pretend to know what that is. I would love to learn more about how we might come up with such a number and if our recent federal targets are anywhere close (my hunch is that they are much lower than is optimal).

It seemed like the zeitgeist amongst housing advocates a year ago (which seemed true to me too) was that the best solution to high housing costs was reducing supply constraints. But now that we've achieved lower housing costs after dramatically reducing immigration, it's unclear if we should really celebrate that. Do we really want lower rents if it comes at the cost of slower economic growth?

Of course the answer depends on the magnitudes in question, which again I don't know, but evaluating that doesn't seem to be a part of the conversation anywhere. Would love to see a post on it.

Samuel Goldring's avatar

The” indigenous” people were settlers who came from Asia . If 5,000 migrated to this new world in one year . Does that mean they can claim all the territory for themselves. If a new group of 5000 Asians arrive 2 years later can the first group seriously tell the 2nd group sorry it’s all ours we were here first. The earth belongs to all of us. Indigenousness is an accident no one is here first and why should we carve . A more serious approach would be how can we productively live together or along side each other Indigenousness is a kind of class or racism an artificial grouping to keep the other out . Time to take a step back and ask how we can embrace each other and not totemicly hold on to land . Learn from territorial mammals who after a minor display of of size and strength make room for each others packs

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?